New prop needed after today...Suggestions?

[Timmy!]

IMO, the spouse needs to know and be comfortable with both things in case an emergency happens. Sometimes we are the only boat out at the lake and if something major happened and I couldn't do one of the parts, she is the only one she can rely on because our lake is in the middle of nowhere.

[Fiveflat]

When I broke my leg wakeboarding back in '99 it was a good thing my brother was with us so his wife could just stay put in the observer seat.

[houstonshark]

Just verified from an old post of mine that I have 1631. If youre not dead set on a cinco. Buy this one, trust me you will not regret it and why risk any prop burn? Ours is a monster out the hole, weve had full ballast and like 8 people on it for about 3200 plus lbs not including gear or fuel and it had no issues...

So as it turns out, I was wrong and didn't have the 537 on my RZR. It was a 1631 like yours but for some reason, it doesn't pull near as hard out of the hole as you describe, even with front ballast at 100% and the rear at 50%. The 1235 has been much better so far but it looks like we are also going to try a 1273 (14.50 X 14.25 VL4B 1.125 .150 Cup) and the new 5 blade 2231 M39 (14.50 X 15.50 VL5B 1.125 .060 Cup).